show sidebar & content

The terrible price of Kenyan flowers

Not so long ago, roses were expensive. Now you can get six blooms for £4 at my local Tescos. The real cost of cheap flowers was revealed to me in all its horror earlier this month when we visited Kenya’s Lake Naivasha, a large freshwater lake in the Rift Valley, formerly home to a thriving eco-system, teeming with fish and birds, and supporting a rich diversity of wildlife in the surrounding hills and bush; from dwarf mongooses to lions and elephants.

Since I was last at Lake Naivasha, it has been systematically raped by the rise of flower farms. When I was here ten years ago I remember seeing a few flower farms, but nothing – nothing – on this monumental scale.

naivasha roses

Thousands of acres of prime lakeside bush and smallholdings have been cleared to make way for hundreds and hundreds of huge polytunnels in which the roses are propagated on an industrial scale.

naivasha polytunnels

The blooms can be harvested and packed using cheap local labour and flown out of Nairobi, which is just a couple of hours drive away, to reach lucrative European markets within a day.

But the true cost of this profitable enterprise beggars belief.

Flowers are thirsty which is why farmers are using Lake Naivasha’s shores; an easy source of the huge quantities of water they need. The lake level has dropped dramatically, from what we saw by 3 or 4 metres in the past 5 to 10 years judging by the vegetation.

We went out for a boat ride on the lake to see the hippos and were disturbed to see some guys dismantling a wooden jetty which was now left high and dry about 100metres from the current lakeshore.
naivasha jetty

Now I’m no expert on water quality, but instead of being a nice deep bluey green, the water was yellowy brown. As the water is extracted and level drops, chemicals used in propagation runs off back into the lake. Local fisherman report significantly smaller catches. And for a lake of that size the hippo and bird populations were laughably small.
naivasha hippo

The polytunnels are not just unsightly, they form an impenetrable barrier for wildlife which must get to the lake to drink. Our guide told us that there are a couple of wildlife corridors which have been left open but that it’s not good enough.

And as we drove to and from our lodge we witnessed the thousands of people who work on the flower farms; queuing up to a get a day’s work; spraying, tending, harvesting and packing the blooms for a few meagre shillings a day – and we saw their cramped and dirty living conditions.
naivasha poor housing
I realised I was looking at precisely the same kind of worker exploitation as Britain experienced in the 19th century, and for the same reasons; population growth, the desperate need for work, greedy company owners (mostly Dutch, Israeli and German as far as we could see) creaming off the profits. Goodness knows what protection, if any, the slaving workers are given for using hazardous chemicals.
naivasha workers

The problem of over-extraction of water has been known about for years. But there is so much money to be made from this blooming business that some unscrupulous greedheads will protect their profits at any cost, even resorting to killing anyone trying to protect the lake. Local resident, film-maker and conservationist Joan Root paid with her life in 2006 when she was murdered at her lakeside home of 25 years.

So next time you’re buying flowers, spare a thought for the thousands of exploited workers, the dying fish, the poisoned waters, the dwindling hippo population and all the creatures of the surrounding bush whose lake they can no longer reach, and for Joan Root …and you won’t ever buy cheap Kenyan blooms again.

2 Responses to The terrible price of Kenyan flowers

  1. Sarah Disney says:

    Is Fairtrade not help these situations? On their website it mentions that they are looking into various alternative ways in which they can get water for irrigation in order to adhere to the Fairtrade standards?

  2. Jane Tomlinson says:

    Hi Sarah – The only water source is the lake. I cannot see how anything ‘Fairtrade’ could help the exploited people, the dying and poisoned lake, the wildlife … the entire ecosystem! I was utterly sickened by what I saw, and I will NEVER buy another Kenyan flower. Whether you do or not must be your choice.
    J
    x

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

This is a demo store for testing purposes — no orders shall be fulfilled.